LG 47LG60 Review

 

Model: LG 47LG60

Reviewer: Jack Burden 
March, 2009

Copyright © 2009 LCDTVBuyingGuide.com. All Rights Reserved.

INTRODUCTION

The LG 47LG60 47" LCD was introduced in the fall of 2008 and runs until the fall of 2009. The LCD has some of the "scarlet" design accents – red trim visible on sides, top and around the stand of the TV. It is very thin at only 2.7" in depth and looks impressive and expensive on its accompanying table stand with the red accents giving a touch of modern class. Processing speed on this unit is up to 120Hz but see our comments below regarding this new feature. It has 1080p resolution and all of the new LG technologies including processing enhancements. It contains 50,000:1 dynamic contrast ratio and 4 HDMI inputs (3 in back, 1 on side).

PICTURE QUALITY RATING: 90.5/100

Test and Optimum Viewing Distance: 12 feet

Up conversion from 480i and 480p: Processing hardware contained in the LG60 did a magnificent job up converting from 480i to native resolution. Images from Seabiscuit and Dave Matthews in Concert DVD appeared crisp and background noise is eliminated. I'm going out on a limb here and stating that the viewer will scarcely will benefit from a Blu Ray player – the processor is that good at up converting standard def signals! There was, however motion lag present throughout the test material, more notably with the True Motion 120Hz turned off, however we felt it a necessary trade off to keep this feature off and preserve the realism of the films.

Note the exceptionally accurate post calibration blue tones in this scene with Dave Matthews.

Shadow and contrast are clearly shown off in this race track scene from Seabiscuit. Note the subtle coloration in the hats which contrasts with the pop of the red lips of the ladies.

720p/1080i/1080p Picture Quality: One very important point about this TV is to turn the True Motion120Hz processing OFF during film content (especially DVDs) to avert the soap opera, contrived appearance that results from this feature. "It looks like cardboard cutouts," was the way one of our viewers aptly described it. Enabling the 120Hz feature while viewing film content disables the directors tricks to make the scene look realistic and decreases depth perception while making unintended content viewable. See "Remote/Menu Functionality" section below for instructions on turning this feature on and off.See our article about 60Hz vs. 120Hz rate practical applications here.

The 47LG60 tested very well in conversion and background noise. Color rendition with HD material was crisp and we enjoyed pop this TV gives to newer content. More impressive was our Diagonal Filter Testing which showed no "jaggies" in horizontal moving bars even near the axis – a near perfect and best of class result (with True Motion feature On).

Watching Iron Man in HD showed off some of the 47LG60s strengths such as the TVs ability to display accurate flesh tones in difficult lighting conditions. However, it also displayed the a of detail in dark shadows such as in the clothing of the characters.

HQV Testing: The 47LG60 passed all tests with most results excellent. The processor got a little confused at intervals during the Film Res Loss Test, but corrected itself quickly.

Black Level: Black levels were sufficient despite being highly constrained by the anti glare screen. At times, the top and bottom bars looked a little washed out and I would not describe the blacks as deep.

Dark Shadow Detail: During scenes from Iron Man lack detail in suits or dark clothing when in a bright scene. Dark material sometimes becomes lumped together and produces losses in depth perception.

Color Rendition/Color Accuracy: While accuracy post calibration is good, colors information appears slightly muted due to the anti glare screen. There is too much softening.

Viewing Angle/Off Axis Viewing: Off angle viewing was adversely affected by the anti glare screen on the LCD. Contrast and black levels start to degrade at just 35 degrees off center. There is also a significant amount of light bleed present at angles in dark material.

Motion Lag: There was certainly motion lag occurring with this LCD, much the same as other high end (or low end) LCDs. While it is evident with all programming, turning On the True Motion 120Hz processing reduces motion lag considerably. Images moving horizontally across the screen, were especially vulnerable.

False Contouring/ Mapping: There was no false contouring or mapping noted. The LCD processing in this area was excellent.

Exceptions: The anti glare screen plays a significant role with this LCD in reducing contrast and black level as well as decreasing dark matter detailing. The anti glare function itself works flawlessly as we did not note any background light disturbance. This TV will be excellent for high ambient light rooms.

OTHER CONSIDERATIONS RATING: 91/100

Video Aspect Ratio Sizing: Again, processing was spot on – sizing looks natural and undistorted on any viewed source.

Inputs: 4 HDMI Inputs, USB port (side entry), 2 Component, RGB 15 pin computer input.

Aesthetic Considerations: Well, there is a lot to say here! The 47LG60 has a gloss black cabinet with a large bottom portion at 6.75" from the bottom of the TV to the bottom of the picture element. A large pendant sized LG light centers this base which presumably houses the video boards and chip set engines of the TV.The LCD is only 2.7" in depth which is awesome! with red accents around the top, sides, and around the chrome colored base. The piece is distinctively art deco and will look great in a modern environment. One strange contradiction is the use of a gloss black cabinet with a stringent anti glare screen – not sure I get that one. It's an interesting piece.

Remote Control/Menu Functionality: The matte black non backlit remote control is easy to use and has an easy to find Input control button on the face. The semi transparent menu is wonderfully easy to use with its handy icons. There is no button on the remote for aspect ratio sizing control. To turn True Motionprocessing Off and On go to Picture setting in the Menu and scroll down to Expert Control. Once there, scroll down to True Motion option half way down and press right arrow key to change On and Off.

The matte black non backlit remote control is easy to use

Audio Output: With film content you will certainly want to turn on the SRX True Surround XT feature as it adds depth and needed warmth to the audio output on this LCD. The sound can be slightly thin and tinny at times. Increasing base and/or decreasing treble also helps.

Features: The touch sensor on/off button (in LG light) is cool. Anti glare screen is great for bright background light but not otherwise. True Motion processing best used only during sports and fast motion programming.

VALUE RATING: 87/100

Price Considerations: At $3300 this is a moderately pricey 47" LCD competing with the new Sony Sharp and Samsung models. It has some nice features – the 2.7" depth and lots of effort put into the design elements.

Quality Comparison: As we can see, so much depends on what features we are using. Our recommendation is to become very familiar with how to turn Off and On the True Motion 120Hz processing feature. In fact LG and others may consider placing a control for it right there on the remote control. Turn it Off for film content and On for sports playback. Processing quality is certainly excellent in this "art deco" LCD television. Black levels, contrast, and viewing angles are all negatively impacted by the anti glare screen technology. But if your viewing room has lots of background light, this could be the TV for you.

OVERALL RATING: 89.75/100

Rating scale from 70 (denoting poorest quality) to 100 (signifying the very best quality). A rating in the 60s for any particular category of a product review indicates a serious defect which causes the product not to operate properly. Picture quality is double-weighted in the Overall Rating Score calculation.

Review Equipment Used: Sencore Color Pro 5000, Sencore Auto Cal Pro, Sencore signal generator.Sony Blu Ray BDP-S1 High Definition DVD player, Sony DVP-S50 DVD player (480i signals).

This review format and all of the headings, sub headings and paragraph titles are part of a copyrighted process. Any unauthorized reproduction or use, either in full or in part, of this product review format is expressly prohibited.

Samsung LN52A750

52" HD LCD TV Resolution 1980 X 1366

Reviewer: Robert Wiley with Jack Burden
Date: November 2008

INTRODUCTION

The Samsung LN52A750 is a current Fall/Winter 2008 LCD TV model which includes non-detachable hidden speakers, 3 HDMI inputs and a 15 pin computer input. The appearance is a black transparent gloss finish with scarlett Touch of Color around the bezel frame. This LCD is next to the top of the lineup for Samsungs current model offerings second only to the LN52A850. Once calibrated, this LCD has a fantastic picture and is packed with features.

PICTURE QUALITY RATING: 94/100

Test and Optimum Viewing Distance: 13 feet

Up conversion from 480i and 480p: As with most LCDs there is notable motion blur and jerkiness in various scenes, fast moving images, and panning side to side. Color information from this Samsung TVis natural and realistic and displays extremely well. Flesh tones were very good in Braveheart andRisky Business. Overall I thought the upconversion processing was excellent delivering clear sharp images on even the most difficult old DVDs. The LN52A750 chip sets took out grain and background noise leaving a smooth, clear image.

Flesh tones, greens and blues looked exceptional in Braveheart

Upconversion processing in Risky Business was superb

720p/1080i/1080p Picture Quality: Motion Lag continues to be an issue even with HD content. We highly recommend that for any film source (I.e. DVDs, Blu Ray, movie programming) that the user turn the Auto Motion Plus (120hz) processing OFF. Otherwise, the picture picks up studio set material which is not intended for viewing. In other words, this feature cuts down on the realism of the picture. Picture depth will also suffer. (See directions on how to turn this function on or off below in the remote/menu function section.) Once the 120hz processing is turned off, the picture returns to an excellent experience with superb detail – yet not in unintended areas. The one drawback is that motion lag will be worse once the 120hz processing is turned off. It's a tradeoff you will want. One important exception to this rule is high definition sports programming in which you will want to utilize the 120hz processing. Wow, football games look incredible! Black levels are some of the best we've seen, helping create depth.

Color information in HD was rich and black levels very good 
from this scene from Blu Ray Ironman

HQV Processor Testing: We tested the Samsung with the Auto Motion Plus feature (120hz) on. With HD signals there was little to no background noise. During video resolution loss testing the LCDs processor performed superbly. Diagonal Filter tests also yielded excellent processing showing little to no jaggies on the horizontal moving bar test. The Samsung LN52A750 has a stellar video processor. The only drawback was during the film resolution loss test, there was slight distortion in the upper right quadrant block of the test screen.

Black Level: Honest black levels characterize this LCD TV. Black levels appear pretty natural due to the transparent plexiglass outer screen (as opposed to an antiglare screen). The black levels are not plasma like but are very good for an LCD.

Dark Shadow Detail: Blacks can get slightly oversaturated at times blotting out detail – especially with some HD content. Overall, though we liked the tradeoff with dark matter detailing still solid.

The colors are accurate and dark shadow detail impressive as in 
the hair in this scene from The Fifth Element

Color Rendition/Color Accuracy: Colors appeared natural and accurate (post calibration) with several of our review DVDs, blues in the mountain scenes and flesh tones on Mel Gibson's face in Braveheart.

Viewing Angle/Off Axis Viewing: Off angle viewing was very good on this LCD. Contrast doesnt begin to degrade until around 120 degrees at side angles – an excellent result. This is due in part to the non-antiglare transparent gloss screen used with this LCD TV as well as the quality of the LCD panel.

Motion Lag: There was motion lag and jerkiness evident in our reviews of Ironman and The Fifth Element. It's a drawback for this and almost any other LCD.

Exceptions: Turn the 120Hz processing OFF when watching film and show content. The screen does throw off a lot of glare on this TV especially for an LCD.

Note: There is some glare noted from the screen which is glossy. While this type of overlay helps with depth and contrast it should be taken into consideration in dark rooms.

OTHER CONSIDERATIONS RATING: 90/100

Inputs: 3 HDMI inputs, 2 component, one 15 pin D sub (for computer) and a USB port round out a generous supply of input compatibility.

Aesthetic Considerations: The LN52A750 is quite attractive if not a bit cheap feeling. It doesnt have the weight that it's previously reviewed brother plasma has. The back panel is made of thin plastic. The plexi overscreen coat is also a little cheap feeling. The Touch of Color accenting is nice yielding that subtle red tone.

The bezel frame of the LCD is too hefty for me at 3" in width on the sides and 2.75" on top and bottom. It's glare can detract from the picture as well.

Remote Control/Menu Functionality: The menu on the LN52A750 is slick looking- transparent but the navigation is not swift. The scrolling wheel on the remote is slow to use and a little awkward. Another negative here is the gloss black remote which shows fingerprints too readily. The remote is backlit but does not have an aspect ratio button on the interface. The source button controls input selection.

To get to the Auto Motion Plus (120Hz) setting go to: Picture, then scroll down to Picture Options, then scroll down to Auto Motion Plus where you can turn it On or Off using the side arrow keys.

Audio Output: Audio output was excellent from our Dolby Digital Test disc. Volume level was plentiful and sound rich and full at just 35% of capacity. Virtual Surround sound effects also impressed us from the 10W X 10W speakers.

Features: Adding to the large increases in features and functionality of the 650 series is the 750 series. Upgraded features in this Samsung TV take network and multi media capability to a higher level. The LCD is MPEG and JPEG compatible using USB 2.0. The LN46A750 LCD series also boasts a Home Viewing Gallery or MPEG3, an internal flash memory with premium content as well as enhanced audio technology through an integrated woofer design. Users can now connect and utilize the data stored in a variety of digital devices, turning their HDTV into a media hub.

Video Aspect Ratio Sizing: Aspect ratio processing and sizing was spot on non-distorted from a variety of input sources. Selection is 16:9, 4:3, Zoom 1, 2, 3.

VALUE RATING: 88/100

For $2400 to $2500 this 52" HD LCD packs a lot of punch. It is near the top of Samsung's lineup for 2008 (the LN52A850 is highest). Price wise, the unit is compatible with Sharp's LC-52D85U, though it is several hundred dollars more than LG's 52LG70. Given its positive features 120hz processing (use for sports only), Touch of Color styling, excellent black levels and viewing angle vs. its negatives motion lag, glare from the screen (from any lighting behind the viewer), large bezel (frame) I put it priced very fairly in a crowded field of entry's. This LCD's strongest point is not price though it is competitive.

OVERALL RATING: 91.50/100

Rating scale from 70 (denoting poorest quality) to 100 (signifying the very best quality). A rating in the 60s for any particular category of a product review indicates a serious defect which causes the product not to operate properly. Picture quality is double-weighted in the Overall Rating Score calculation.

Review Equipment Used: Sony Blu Ray BDP-S1 High Definition DVD player, Sony DVP-S50 DVD player, JVC HM-DH40000U HD Video Cassete player, Sencore Color Pro 5000, Sencore Auto Cal Pro, Sencore signal generator.

This review format and all of the headings, sub headings and paragraph titles are part of a copyrighted process. Any unauthorized reproduction or use, either in full or in part, of this product review format is expressly prohibited.

Sony KDL-46XBR8 Review

 

Description: 1920 X 1080 (1080p) 46" Diagonal LCD TV with LED Backlight
Dimensions: See Specifications Here
Power Consumption: 350W
Reviewer: Robert Wiley
Date: April 2009

Test and Optimum Viewing Distance: 13

720p/1080i/1080p HD Picture Quality: One feature that we found very necessary was the Noise reduction feature. 

Once turning on this setting option, the picture was crisp and clear with very little about which to complain. There is bright color, great contrast and black levels and most surprising to us – plasma-like viewing angles. There was some false contouring in dark on bright areas of the picture. This "mapping" of dark matter will not be noticed if one is 15 feet or more from the television. However, it is noticeable from a closer distance. Other than that, another defining plasma-like characteristic is depth perception with HD signals which is excellent.

This shot of Sam Shepard in Black Hawk Down demonstates the XBR's contrast capabilities with deep blacks and excellent light reflection.

See the crisp detail in the helicopter in this shot from the Blu Ray version of Black Hawk Down.

Up conversion from 480i and 480p: 2:35:1 DVDs should be viewed in the Zoom aspect picture mode controlled by the Wide button on the remote control. While this mode properly displays the aspect of the content, it does soften the picture giving a slightly blurred appearance. This was one of the only drawbacks from the XBR8's picture. Aside from that the Bravia Engine 2 processed signals extremely well.

A scene from 480i input from Braveheart shows off the contrast of this LED backlit TV as daylight penetrates illuminating the veil of the princess. But notice that the image is overly soft due to using the Zoom aspect ratio to gain the correct sizing alternative.

Black Level: Our post calibration contrast measurement was a fairly impressive 228 to 1. While this still is well short of many top tier plasma TVs which we've measured at 700 to 1, it is a good result for an LCD. See our full calibration report here. I was surprised by how deep and penetrating the blacks were on this LCD – perhaps the best black levels we've seen on an LCD though a couple of new Samsung LCDs may rival them.

Dark Shadow Detail: No complaints in this department aside from the occasional mapping issue. Dark areas of images were detailed and easily discernible.

This shot shows in awesome detail the sweat glistening on the drivers face in a scene from the HD version of Black Hawk Down.

Color Rendition/Color Accuracy: The XBR8 dialed in nicely to D6500 and color information appeared natural and not over baked like so many expensive LCDs. At times we found ourselves pleasantly glued to a scene just enjoying the realistic, colorful images.

Notice the variation and realism of the flesh tones in this HD image from our Dolby test disk.

Viewing Angle/Off Axis Viewing: The XBR8 has the best viewing angle capability we've seen on an LCD. We estimated that contrast does not start to degrade until about 75 degrees – a superb result – especially for an LCD TV. It's really a plasma-like result.

Motion Lag: There was some notable jerkiness when the camera panned from side to side. Sony does not give a clear option for accessing the 120Hz processing. Instead, they give a few advanced picture settings such as Motion Enhancer and Game Modes. So, it was impossible to know whether we were viewing images in 60Hz or 120Hz. We thought the XBR8 did a good job with reduction of motion lag during fast moving scenes. It would be nice to clearly be able to turn the 120hz processing off if wanted – to see the difference.

Video Features: We do not normal recommend using many of the "enhancing" features present on todays TVs which typically add video noise. However, the Noise Reduction option on the XBR8 is a favorable feature. We recommend placing it on the medium setting which greatly helps to reduce background motion artifacts without softening the picture too much.

Video Aspect Ratio Sizing: The Wide button on the remote controls aspect ratio options. There are more aspect ratio options for HDMI input content including Wide, Wide Zoom, Normal, Full, H Stretch, Zoom.

Inputs: 4 HDMI inputs round out a complete enough set of input options. Has Firewire and USB port as well as a CAT 5 input jack.

Aesthetic Considerations: While an attractive TV, there are no real design style improvements over past models. One drawback we immediately noticed in the XBR8 is the 6" depth cabinet which is no doubt caused by the new LED lighting system. Still, that is a bulky depth especially if wall mounting. The speakers now are housed on the sides of the "floating" glass.

Remote Control/Menu Funtionality: The Xross Media Bar menu system is a cool looking if not a little quirky to use at first. Once accustomed to it, it is a fun little feature scrolling through the numerous advanced settings which for the most part you will want to avoid. One that you do want to turn on is the Noise Reduction function. It's annoying to have to scroll through inputs each time one needs to change input sources (for instance from HDMI to composite). We would like to see discrete input buttons on the remote control. The remote control is 10" long, has a great backlight feature, is well designed, and has a convenient aspect ratio button.

Audio Output: We felt the sound was flat without enough definition when listening to the Ramsey Lewis Jazz ensemble in our HD test disc. There was no crispness in the high hat. Sound output was dull and the speakers did not put out sufficient volume for the size.

Features: There is a new Video Game mode as well as Bravia Sync option for communicating with other Sony equipment.

Note: At 350 watts the Bravia 46XBR8 is an energy hog in plasma like fashion – no doubt due to those new LED backlights.

Price Considerations: Priced stiffly at $3999 from almost all dealers this LCD is a pricey option. Samung, and LG have competing LED backlit models which are a bit less expensive, but not having reviewed them yet it's difficult to make a price comparison. The Samsung LN55A950 is a similar LED backlit LCD and costs about $1000 less. The playing field will narrow somewhat soon with LG entering this size LED backlit LCD market, but for now that's the whole competitive landscape if you take plasma out of the picture.

A 50" top of the line Plasma TV with similar picture quality, excellent viewing angles, and deep rich black levels will set you back half as much as the 46XBR8. The LED backlit XBR8 has the one advantage of being brighter in light scenes.

Rating scale from 70 (denoting poorest quality) to 100 (signifying the very best quality). A rating in the 60s for any particular category of a product review indicates a serious defect which causes the product not to operate properly. Picture quality is double-weighted in the Overall Rating Score calculation.

Review Equipment Used: Sony Blu Ray BDP-S1 High Definition DVD player, Sony DVP-S50 DVD player, Sencore Color Pro 5000, Sencore Auto Cal Pro, Sencore signal generator.

This review format and all of the headings, sub headings and paragraph titles are part of a copyrighted process. Any unauthorized reproduction or use, either in full or in part, of this product review format is expressly prohibited.

Copyright © 2009 LCDTVBuyingGuide.com. All Rights Reserved.

Sharp LC-46D65U Review

Description: Full HD 1080p 60Hz 46" Diagonal LCD TV
Power Consumption: 254W
Reviewer: Jack Burden
Date: April 2009

Test and Optimum Viewing Distance: 13 feet

720p/1080i/1080p Picture Quality: The HD picture on the LC-46D65U was very defined once we calibrated the unit. There was a certain lack of depth as the picture information appeared somewhat flat to me. I believe this was caused in part by an overactive anti-glare screen, which also decreases the appearance of contrast in a brightly lit room. There was also a evident lack of dark shadow detail. Color information appeared natural and not over saturated.

Note the lack of dark shadow detail in this HD image from The Last Mutiny.

Up conversion from 480i and 480p: The Sharp has stellar processing in some cases. Horizontal and Vertical line information was displayed with no dithering in our HQV Film Resolution Loss Test. The processing was better than even many very high end TVs and one of the only units testing that did not exhibit strobing during this test in any of the test boxes.

Up conversion from a 480i signal was solid but the picture went a little soft. With a 2:35:1 DVD one needs to use the Zoom aspect ratio feature which weakens definition in the picture even more.

The blinds in the background in this scene from Step Mom displayed with no dithering movement and artifacts. This is an impressive result verifying excellent internal processing boards.

Black Level: Black levels appear solid from front and center but off to the side at 40 degrees blacks begin fading to a dark purplish hue and this effect remains at further angles.

Note the difference in the top and bottom bars from the front and at a 40 degree angle. In the picture at right from this scene from Perfume it's easy to note the dark purple hue creeping into blacks.

Dark Shadow Detail: The LC-46D65U had relatively weak dark shadow detail which would be expected with the deficient contrast ratio we tested. See Calibration measurements and contrast here.

The LC-46D65U struggled with dark shadow detail as in this scene from The San Fransisco Philarmonic playing in our Dolby Test DVD. Note the lack of detail in darker areas of clothing.

Color Rendition/Color Accuracy: Once calibrated, color information on the LC-46D65U appeared realistic and vibrant.

We felt colors were very realistic overall but that flesh tones were slightly washed out as in these two scenes from the HD version of comedy Benchwarmers.

Viewing Angle/Off Axis Viewing: As noted in black level section above, contrast begins to degrade at around 40 degrees on this LCD. Sharp is known for having high quality LCD panels which they manufacture at their own factories, so I was surprised at this result. We suspect it has to do with the anti-glare screen contained on this LCD.

Motion Lag: With fast motion the Sharp performed very well for an LCD, displaying the increased response rate present on this model to 8ms. In scenes when the camera panned from side to side there was obvious jerkiness as if there camera was hitting bumps along the way. Though this is common with LCD TVs, it is never pleasant. This was also apparent in our HQV Stadium seating test. No moire' pattern appeared but the jerkiness as the camera tracked from one end of the stadium to the other was apparent.

False Contouring/ Mapping: There was some false contouring and mapping apparent in 480i test content. Lack of detail in dark areas also accentuated blotching.

Exceptions: While the anti-glare screen on this LCD does reduce a lot of glare from ambient lighting, it causes contrast and black levels to degrade at early angles.

Video Aspect Ratio Sizing: With most inputs there are 4 options S. Stretch, Zoom, Side Bar, Stretch. You will want to use the Zoom setting for 2:35:1 DVDs. With HDMI input signals there is the addition of Dot by Dot and Full Screen options. The Sharp manual gives excellent instruction about which setting to use with varying content.

Using the Zoom setting while viewing the 2:35:1 480i DVD Step Mom rendered images a little soft as in this picture of the horse farm. Notice the blurry edges around the horses.

Inputs: As with most all TVs these days the Sharp has plenty of inputs. There are 5 HDMI inputs with one of these housed conveniently on the side of the TV. There is also a USB port placed there which allows the user to quickly load and view pictures or other content. T

Aesthetic Considerations: The Sharp LC-46D65U scores very well in this category with nice clean lines and small non-distracting bezel. There is a thin gray metal speaker grill strip accented in the bottom of the unit. We measure the depth at an impressively sleek 3.8" making this TV ideal to wall mount.

Remote Control/Menu Functionality: There is a convenient set of controls placed on the side of the TV, out of view, but easily accessible should you misplace your remote control or need this option for a trade show. The accompanying manual gives clear instruction.

Audio Output: The Sharp had good voluminous sound and relatively crisp compared to most inbuilt speakers. It had good pop in the high and mid ranges as we could even discern fret buzz during replay of our Dave Matthews Dolby Digital test DVD. The bass however was weak even with the bass enhancer feature cranked all the way to 10. Overall though I thought the audio performance for TV speakers was excellent.

Price/Quality Considerations: On a quality comparison with the nearest competitors we would pit this Sharp LCD more squarely against LG, Mitsubishi, and Samsung. The Samsung LN46A550 is priced about the same as the Sharp LC-46D65U at around $1150 and we put the quality comparison of these two units in the same ball park. The Mistubishi LT-46148 is priced just above those two at $1200. The LG 47LG50 is priced just below at $1099. This Sharp offering is priced right.

Rating scale from 70 (denoting poorest quality) to 100 (signifying the very best quality). A rating in the 60s for any particular category of a product review indicates a serious defect which causes the product not to operate properly. Picture quality is double-weighted in the Overall Rating Score calculation.

Review Equipment Used: Sony Blu Ray BDP-S1 High Definition DVD player, Sony DVP-S50 DVD player, JVC HM-DH40000U HD Video Cassete player, Sencore Color Pro 5000, Sencore Auto Cal Pro, Sencore signal generator.

This review format and all of the headings, sub headings and paragraph titles are part of a copyrighted process. Any unauthorized reproduction or use, either in full or in part, of this product review format is expressly prohibited.

Copyright © 2009 LCDTVBuyingGuide.com. All Rights Reserved.

LG 47LGX Review

Description: 47" HD LCD 1980 X 1366 Resolution

Reviewer: Robert Wiley
November 2008

INTRODUCTION TO LG 47LGX

The LG 47LGX is a winter 2008 TV model. The LCD has some of the "scarlet" design accents – red trim visible on sides, top and around the stand of the TV. It has the exceptionally deep bottom portion cabinet where many of the electronic components must be stored to enable its stunning 1.8" in depth. The other big upgrade over the LG60 series is the 120Hz processing capability. The LG 47LGX has 1080p resolution and all of the new LG technologies including processing enhancements. It contains 50,000:1 dynamic contrast ratio and 4 HDMI inputs (3 in back, 1 on side).

PICTURE QUALITY RATING: 87/100

Prior to viewing we performed some fine calibration on this the LG 47LGX. See calibration settings at the bottom of the review to calibrate your TV if you own one.

Test and Optimum Viewing Distance: 12 feet

The Fresh Contrast features improved depth but notice
a little haziness in top right section of picture

720p/1080i/1080p Picture Quality: One feature we found to increase depth in HD film content is the Fresh Contrast function. Turning on this feature takes out the distracting hazy appearance from the anti glare screen and improves contrast considerably. A further piece of advice to follow prior to DVD and film content viewing is to turn off the True Motion 120Hz processing. This will help give the user a much more realistic picture without so much focus on the background picture set information. See "Remote/Menu Functionality" section below for instructions on turning this feature on and off. It seems difficult to produce a bright enough picture sometimes with the Blu Ray version of Master and Commander. However, the LG 47LGX did so while fighting any incoming glare effectively as well. The anti glare screen is amazing. Ambient light just gets lost in the screen. Overall, the picture with HD content was slightly hazy, crisp, clean, with some motion lag and side to side jerkiness. Color information displayed admirably once the TV was calibrated (click here for calibrations).

Upconversion processing is so good in this TV that
an upconverting DVD player is unncessary.

Up conversion from 480i and 480p: Processing hardware contained in the LGX did a magnificent job up converting from 480i to native resolution. Images from Braveheart and Tomorrow Never Dies were crisp and background noise is nearly eliminated. Indeed the LGX's upconversion processing prowess is so good that a consumer doesnt even need an upconverting DVD player. Let the TV do the work. I would even be hesitant about purchasing a Blu Ray player. There was, however motion lag present throughout the test material, more notably with the True Motion 120Hz turned off, however we felt it a necessary trade off to keep this feature off and preserve the realism of the films.

The 47LGX passed our HQV testing with most results excellent. The processor got a little confused at intervals during the Film Resolution Loss Test, but corrected itself quickly. There was little to no moire' pattern during the stadium seating section of the FRLT. There was also some flicking background noise appearing in our HD Noise Test. Overall the TV's processing chip sets passed our tests easily.

Black Level: Black levels were sufficient despite being highly constrained by the anti glare screen. At times, the top and bottom bars looked a little washed out and I would not describe the blacks as deep. This was also proved out in our contrast ratio measurement checkerboard testing with the 47LGX rendering less than stellar results. Much of this results from the anti glare screen.

Dark Shadow Detail: During scenes from Master and Commander there was decent detail in the inner cabin scenes. Clothing wrinkles showed up but again were hurt by the anti glare screen. Dark material sometimes becomes lumped together and produces losses in depth perception.

Color information appears slightly muted due to the anti glare screen. Post calibration flesh tones duringBraveheart were not rich appearing slightly green.

Off angle viewing was adversely affected by the anti glare screen on the LCD. Contrast and black levels start to degrade at just 35 degrees off center. There is also a significant amount of light bleed present at angles in dark material.

Motion Lag: There was certainly motion lag occurring with this LCD, much the same as other high end (or low end) LCDs. While it is evident with all programming, turning On the True Motion 120Hz processing reduces motion lag considerably. Images moving horizontally across the screen, were especially vulnerable.

There is a trade-off between picture realism and motion lag 
with True Motion on or off. We preferred it off.

False Contouring/ Mapping: There was no false contouring or mapping noted. The LCD processing in this area was excellent.

Exceptions: The anti glare screen plays a significant role with this LCD in reducing contrast and black level as well as decreasing dark matter detailing. The anti glare function itself works flawlessly as we did not note any background light disturbance.

This TV will be excellent for high ambient light rooms.

OTHER CONSIDERATIONS RATING FOR LG 47LGX: 88/100

Video Aspect Ratio Sizing: Again, processing was spot on – sizing looks natural and undistorted on any viewed source. During scenes from Master and Commander Captain Aubrey and Dr. Maturin's features look as normal as if they were sitting in the room with you. There was no side to side "stretch".

Inputs: 4 HDMI Inputs, USB port (side entry), 2 Component, RGB 15 pin computer input.

Appearance: Well, there is a lot to say here! The 47LGX has a gloss black cabinet with a large bottom portion at 6.75" from the bottom of the TV to the bottom of the picture element. A large pendant sized LG light centers this base which presumably houses the video boards and chip set engines of the TV. The LCD is only 1.8" in depth which is awesome! with red accents around the top, sides, and around the chrome colored base. The piece is distinctively art deco and will look great in a modern environment. One strange contradiction is the use of a gloss black cabinet with a stringent anti glare screen – not sure I get that one.

The matte black non backlit remote control is easy to use

Functionality: The menu functionality is one of the easiest to understand and navigate that we have come across. The ten point white balance scale makes calibration more exacting and as mentioned, the Clear Voice technology not only works but is necessary. The matte black non backlit remote is also ease to use, but lacks an aspect ratio button.

Audio: First and foremost, you will want to turn on the Clear Voice technology with any TV programming or film content. Not having to strain to hear verbiage is a huge plus. You will also want to initiate the SRX True Surround XT feature as it adds depth and needed warmth to the audio output.

Extra Features: The touch sensor on/off button (in LG light) is cool. Anti glare screen is great for bright back lighting. True Motion processing best used only during sports and fast motion programming.

Samsung LN52A850

52" HD LCD 1980 X 1366 Resolution 

Reviewer: Robert Wiley with Jack Burden

INTRODUCTION

The LN52A850 is the newest high end TV in Samsungs Winter 2008/2009 lineup. One of the key feature differences is the new DLNA compliance certification of this TV over the LN52A750. Another big feature difference is the slim 1.9" cabinet housing. It certainly looks sleek on the table stand. The Touch of Color red accents remain on this series. The 120Hz refresh rate (Auto Motion Plus) feature is still present as well. Find out below how we rate all these features (one especially needs be careful with the 120Hz refresh rate).

PICTURE QUALITY RATING: 93/100

Test and Optimum Viewing Distance: 13 feet

This scene from 300 shows the excellent definition and rich color of the LN52A850

720p/1080i/1080p Picture Quality: Color information with HD content is vibrant and accurate. Many LCD TVs have the tendency to oversaturate color information but the Samsung LN52A850 displays accurate, realistic colors along with deeply penetrating blacks to produce excellent depth. It's important to note again that the 120Hz (auto motion plus) processing feature needs to be turned off to maximize depth and not introduce a contrived appearance. You will be rewarded by this strategy. Dark Shadow detail in the Blu Ray version of 300 occasionally got oversaturated with blacks losing detail.

Accurate color information is a trademark of this excellent TV as displayed 
here in the Blu Ray version of Little Man

Up conversion from 480i and 480p: Processing is excellent on this high end TV. An excellent chip set is one of the upgrades you get when moving up the offering ladder of a brand like Samsung.The processing chip sets did an excellent job with 3:2 pulldown upconversion to native resolution – removing motion artifacts and smoothing images. I was very impressed. Motion lag and some jerkiness does remain as in most LCDs even with the 120Hz processing feature turned on.

HQV Processor Testing: We tested the Samsung TV with the Auto Motion Plus feature (120hz) on. With HD signals there was little to no background noise. During video resolution loss testing the LCDs processor performed superbly. Diagonal Filter tests also yielded excellent processing showing little to no jaggies on the horizontal moving bar test. The LN52A850 has a stellar video processor. The only drawback was during the film resolution loss test, there was slight distortion in the upper right quadrant block of the test screen.

Black Level: Honest black levels characterize this LCD TV. Black levels appear natural and without the haziness which is pervasive of most LCD TVs. This is partly due to the transparent plexiglass outer screen as opposed to a severe anti glare screen. The black levels are nearly plasma like.

Dark Shadow Detail: Blacks can get slightly oversaturated at times blotting out detail – especially with some HD content. Overall, though we liked the tradeoff with dark matter detailing still solid.

Shadow detail was sometimes overpowered by oversaturating blacks 
as seen in the hair of Lena Headey in 300

Viewing Angle/Off Axis Viewing: This Samsung TV has excellent viewing angle for an LCD – nearly 120 degrees before degrading contrast.

Motion Lag: As mentioned above there was consistent motion lag and jerkiness with almost any signal and especially when panning side to side. The 120Hz feature does cut down on motion lag but is not recommended for film content.

Exceptions: We recommend turing off the Auto Motion Plus feature when viewing film based content including TV programming. There is a good bit of glare from the gloss screen, but it's a tradeoff we like.

OTHER CONSIDERATIONS RATING: 92/100

Video Aspect Ratio Sizing: Aspect ratio processing and sizing was spot on non-distorted from a variety of input sources. Selection is 16:9, 4:3, Zoom 1, 2, 3.

Inputs: There is plenty of input selection including 3 HDMI inputs, 2 component, one 15 pin D sub (for computer). This TV also adds an Infolink USB port.

Aesthetic Considerations: The LN52A850 is quite attractive at only 1.9" depth its one of the thinnest on the market. The Touch of Color is nice and classy. The bezel frame is a little large for me at 2.75" on top and bottom (of the screen). It can throw off significant glare as our pictures show.

The thumb wheel is slick but not fast enough for us.

Remote Control/Menu Functionality: The menu system on the on the LN52A850 has an excellent little tutorial which helps the user understand what each function does. It's a slick looking- transparent menu but the scrolling navigation wheel is not fast to use. It's a little cumbersome when you want to make a quick adjustment. Another negative here is the gloss black remote which shows fingerprints too readily. The remote is backlit but does not have an aspect ratio button on it. The source button controls input selection.

To get to the Auto Motion Plus (120Hz) setting go to: Picture, then scroll down to Picture Options, then scroll down to Auto Motion Plus where you can turn it On or Off using the side arrow keys.

Audio Output: Audio output was excellent from our Dolby Digital Test disc. Volume level was plentiful and sound rich and full at just 35% of capacity. Virtual Surround sound effects also impressed us from the 10W X 10W speakers.

Features: Adding to the large increases in features and functionality of the 750 series such as Home Viewing Gallery or MPEG3 is the 1.9" depth and DLNA compliance (available only through certain devices using certain software. The aesthetics otherwise are very similar as is the menu system.

VALUE RATING: 85/100

At around $2500 this 52" LCD offers a ton of value. It's got a great feature set and picture and the 1.9" depth is a premium feature. This LCD sells at a nice discount to its Sony competition KDL-52XBR6 and just a slight premium to its own brother the Samsung LN52A750. Other price/quality competitors such as the LG 52LG60 and the Sharp LC-52D85U do sell at several hundred dollars discount to this LCD. It's a richly competitive LCD size range with most brands having several models in this important size category. In a crowded field of entries this LCD's strongest point is not its price.

OVERALL RATING: 90.75/100

Rating scale from 70 (denoting poorest quality) to 100 (signifying the very best quality). A rating in the 60s for any particular category of a product review indicates a serious defect which causes the product not to operate properly. Picture quality is double-weighted in the Overall Rating Score calculation.

Review Equipment Used: Sony Blu Ray BDP-S1 High Definition DVD player, Sony DVP-S50 DVD player, JVC HM-DH40000U HD Video Cassete player, Sencore Color Pro 5000, Sencore Auto Cal Pro, Sencore signal generator.

This review format and all of the headings, sub headings and paragraph titles are part of a copyrighted process. Any unauthorized reproduction or use, either in full or in part, of this product review format is expressly prohibited.

mat is expressly prohibited.

LG 42LGX Review

Model: LG 42LGX
Description: 42" HD LCD
Reviewer: Jack Burden with Robert Wiley
Date: October 2008

Copyright © 2008 LCDTVBuyingGuide.com. All Rights Reserved.

INTRODUCTION

The LG 42LGX is a current fall 2008 TV model. The LCD has some of the "scarlet" design accents – red trim visible on sides, top and around the stand of the TV. The top upgrades in this LCD is the depth of only 1.8" and its 120Hz processing capability. It has 1080p resolution and all of the new LG technologies including processing enhancements. It contains 50,000:1 dynamic contrast ratio and 4 HDMI inputs (3 in back, 1 on side).

PICTURE QUALITY RATING: 91/100

Test and Optimum Viewing Distance: 12 feet

Processing hardware contained in the LGX did a magnificent
job up converting from 480i to native resolution.

Up conversion from 480i and 480p: Processing hardware contained in the LGX did a magnificent job up converting from 480i to native resolution. Images from Braveheart, Risky Business, andTomorrow Never Dies were crisp and background noise is eliminated. I'm going out on a limb here and stating that the viewer will scarcely will benefit from a Blu Ray player – the processor is that good at up converting standard def signals! There was, however motion lag present throughout the test material, more notably with the True Motion 120Hz turned off, however we felt it a necessary trade off to keep this feature off and preserve the realism of the films.

The Departed showed off excellent processing with no 
background noise in the horizontal blinds.

720p/1080i/1080p Picture Quality: Viewing the "blind" scene with Martin Sheen, Mark Walberg, and Leonardo Di Caprio in the Blue Ray version of The Departed showed off excellent processing with no background noise in the horizontal blinds. This was also true with our HQV HD Noise Test which showed very slight background noise. More impressive was our Diagonal Filter Testing which showed no "jaggies" in horizontal moving bars even near the axis – a near perfect and best of class result (with True Motion feature On). Iron Man scenes were detailed if not slightly hazy during dark scenes showing the building of the suit in the studio.

HQV Testing: The 42LGX passed all tests with most results excellent. The processor got a little confused at intervals during the Film Res Loss Test, but corrected itself quickly.

Black Level: Black levels were sufficient despite being highly constrained by the anti glare screen. At times, the top and bottom bars looked a little washed out and I would not describe the blacks as deep.

Iron Man scenes were detailed if not slightly hazy during dark scenes

Dark Shadow Detail: During scenes from Iron Man and The Departed, lack of detail in suits of dark clothing when in a bright scene. Dark material sometimes becomes lumped together and produces losses in depth perception.

Color Rendition/Color Accuracy: Colors information appears slightly muted due to the anti glare screen. Post calibration flesh tones during Braveheart and Risky Businesswere not rich appearing a little too green.

Viewing Angle/Off Axis Viewing: Off angle viewing was adversely affected by the anti glare screen on the LCD. Contrast and black levels start to degrade at just 35 degrees off center. There is also a significant amount of light bleed present at angles in dark material.

Motion Lag: There was certainly motion lag occurring with this LCD, much the same as other high end (or low end) LCDs. While it is evident with all programming, turning On the True Motion 120Hz processing reduces motion lag considerably. Images moving horizontally across the screen, were especially vulnerable.

False Contouring/ Mapping: There was no false contouring or mapping noted. The LCD processing in this area was excellent.

Exceptions: The anti glare screen plays a significant role with this LCD in reducing contrast and black level as well as decreasing dark matter detailing. The anti glare function itself works flawlessly as we did not note any background light disturbance. This TV will be excellent for high ambient light rooms.

OTHER CONSIDERATIONS RATING: 88/100

Video Aspect Ratio Sizing: Again, processing was spot on – sizing looks natural and undistorted on any viewed source.

Inputs: 4 HDMI Inputs, USB port (side entry), 2 Component, RGB 15 pin computer input.

Aesthetic Considerations: Well, there is a lot to say here! The 42LGX has a gloss black cabinet with a large bottom portion at 6.75" from the bottom of the TV to the bottom of the picture element. A large pendant sized LG light centers this base which presumably houses the video boards and chip set engines of the TV.The LCD is only 1.8" in depth which is awesome! with red accents around the top, sides, and around the chrome colored base. The piece is distinctively art deco and will look great in a modern environment. One strange contradiction is the use of a gloss black cabinet with a stringent anti glare screen – not sure I get that one.

The matte black non backlit remote control is easy to use

Remote Control/Menu Functionality: The matte black non backlit remote control is easy to use and has an easy to find Input control button on the face. The semi transparent menu is wonderfully easy to use with its handy icons. There is no button on the remote for aspect ratio sizing control. To turn True Motionprocessing Off and On go to Picture setting in the Menu and scroll down to Expert Control. Once there, scroll down to True Motion option half way down and press right arrow key to change On and Off.

The semi transparent menu is wonderfully easy to use with its handy icons

Audio Output: With film content you will certainly want to use the SRX True Surround XT feature as it adds depth and needed warmth to the audio output on this LCD. The sound can be slightly thin and tinny at times. Increasing bass and/or decreasing treble also helps.

Features: The touch sensor on/off button (in LG light) is cool. Anti glare screen is great for bright back lighting. True Motion processing best used only during sports and fast motion programming.

VALUE RATING: 84/100

Price Considerations: At $2100 this is a pricey 42" LCD competing with the new Sony KDL 40XBR6 and the highest end LCDs from Samsung and Sharp. It has some nice features – the 1.8" depth and lots of effort put into the design elements.

Quality Comparison: As we can see, so much depends on what features we are using. Our recommendation is to become very familiar with how to turn Off and On the True Motion 120Hz processing feature. In fact LG and others may consider placing a control for it right there on the remote control. Turn it Off for film content and On for sports playback. Processing quality is certainly excellent in this "art deco" LCD television. Black levels, contrast, and viewing angles are all negatively impacted by the anti glare screen technology. But if your viewing room has lots of background light, this could be the TV for you.

OVERALL RATING: 88.5/100

Rating scale from 70 (denoting poorest quality) to 100 (signifying the very best quality). A rating in the 60s for any particular category of a product review indicates a serious defect which causes the product not to operate properly. Picture quality is double-weighted in the Overall Rating Score calculation.

Review Equipment Used: Sony Blu Ray BDP-S1 High Definition DVD player, Sony DVP-S50 DVD player, JVC HM-DH40000U HD Video Cassete player, Sencore Color Pro 5000, Sencore Auto Cal Pro, Sencore signal generator.

This review format and all of the headings, sub headings and paragraph titles are part of a copyrighted process. Any unauthorized reproduction or use, either in full or in part, of this product review format is expressly prohibited.